On Worthwhile Questions & the Mind of Christ – Br. Keith Nelson
Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Br. Keith Nelson
Preached at the Church of the Holy Comforter, Vienna, VA
Matthew 21:23-32
Philippians 2:1-13
In this morning’s passage from Matthew, we encounter Jesus posing a question. One of Jesus’ distinctive teaching methods is replying to a question with a question.
The chief priests and elders pose the question: “By what authority are you doing these things, and who gave you this authority?” (Matthew 21:23). By this point in Matthew’s narrative, it has become clear that this is not an authentic question, because they are not genuinely receptive to Jesus’ answer. So Jesus skillfully counters the question with a question of his own.
He asks: “Did the baptism of John come from heaven, or was it of human origin?” (Matthew 21:25).
Their answer, “We do not know,” is as inauthentic as the question. It is a feigned ignorance in order both to retain their own authority and avoid running afoul of public opinion. Jesus slips from their trap with rhetorical grace. Jesus offers answers – but they come to those who are willing to ask hard questions, and to follow those questions wherever they lead, even to the foot of the cross.
When I first arrived at the monastery twelve years ago, the burning question on my heart was: “Am I really meant to be a monk?”
This is not a question with a quick or easy answer. So before a man even enters the first stage of monastic formation, the novitiate, he lives alongside the Brothers for six months as a Postulant – that is, one who asks questions. And initially there are many questions, from the practical and mundane to the spiritual and existential. The monastery is shaped and ordered by what is called a Rule: a pattern of values and practices that add up to a distinct way of discipleship in the Church. As the Rule and the Spirit collaborate to form the mind of Christ in us more deeply, the questions become more refined. While at first this feels like watching a radish grow, if all goes as it should, the answers take root and grow by trusting the Sower, one day at a time. We discover ourselves by forgetting ourselves, until the response we are meant to make takes shape.
In our reading from the letter to the Philippians, Paul offers a remarkable interpretation of an ancient Christian hymn whose central theme is the mind of Christ. To know – and to receive – this mind is to make Christ the center, the one from whom all Truth radiates and infuses our lives.
But this Truth goes on provoking questions as our capacity to receive more of the Truth grows!
Our Rule captures the dynamism of this process when it states, “Our faithfulness to our calling will be seen by the ways in which we fearlessly subject our life to hard questions in the light of the gospel, resist inertia and rigidity, minister to one another generously as equals, and stay open to the fresh inspiration of the Spirit.”1
According to that vision, the one who receives the mind of Christ continues to grow only in proportion to their readiness to ask Jesus questions, and to change in response to the questions he poses.
In Philippians 2:5-11, we hear:
“Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus,
who, though he was in the form of God,
did not regard equality with God
as something to be exploited,
but emptied himself,
taking the form of a slave,
being born in human likeness.
And being found in human form,
he humbled himself
and became obedient to the point of death –
even death on a cross.
Therefore God also highly exalted him
and gave him the name
that is above every name,
so that at the name of Jesus
every knee should bend,
in heaven and on earth and under the earth,
and every tongue should confess
that Jesus Christ is Lord,
to the glory of God the Father.”
What is the nature of Christ’s genuine authority?
For Paul, the key is found in one Greek word: kenosis, or self-emptying. Christ, the Son of God and filled with all God’s fullness and glory, chose a voluntary path of humility. The earliest Christians came to see this not only in the life of Jesus of Nazareth, who was born, lived, and died among them. By reflecting on the pattern of his living and dying, they came to believe that this self-spending is a central facet of God’s nature. By this self-emptying, God made room for time and space to be before the beginning. Jesus listened deeply to this calling to give all that he had and all that he was in imitation of this divine generosity. Once chosen, it was a path he followed all the way to the cross.
This ancient hymn reflects the shape of that cosmic descent. We can imagine an enormous “U,” with “death on a cross” as the absolute lowest point. Jesus is the subject of every verb in that downward sequence. There is a pause, a silence – an emptiness.
The final question Jesus asks in Matthew’s Gospel is: “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (Matthew 27:46). It is into this silence and emptiness that the question is directed.
Yet the question is itself a prayer. And there is a reply. The emphatic “Therefore” signals a hinge rather than an ending. Now God is the subject of every verb, every upward step a response to Christ’s free self-offering. The staircase of resurrection rises from the abyss. It is through the free gift of self for the life of the world that the authority of God rests on Jesus Christ.
It is easy to see how starkly this vision of authority contrasts with the self-will, self-augmentation, self-fulfillment, or self-aggrandizement so often at the core of worldly authority. There is again one Greek word at the center of Paul’s critique of this path of egoic upward mobility: kenodoxia. Usually translated vainglory, it literally means “empty glory.” If self-emptying, self-spending love is God’s central motive at work in Christ, vainglory is its inverse. It is all appearance and no substance; the weight of public approval over genuine moral character. It is a house built on sand rather than founded on rock.
There is, of course, a whole spectrum of motivations in the gray space between these two poles. Our task is, on balance, to ensure that the weight of our fundamental selfhood tips in the direction of the new life we find in Christ.
How can we make the authority of Christ the center of all that we think and do and are? And how can that authority become the living heart of a community called together in Christ’s name?
Paul names the ways that he has seen the Philippians begin to make Christ the center: by “encouragement in Christ; consolation from love; sharing in the Spirit; compassion and sympathy” (Philippians 2:1). And he gives them some further keys for gathering up this good beginning in values and practices into the collective offering of a self-emptying community: being of the same mind – the same habitual attitude, “one souled” – and doing nothing with its primary motivation or origin in the small self.
As a monk, I am of course biased. But it is not too hard to imagine Paul suggesting to the Philippians the basic outline of a Rule of Life: the mind of Christ at work in each member drawing its coordinated life, work, and worship into a single mind, shaped by the same core motivation. The fine point of this motivation would have needed reshaping daily by “hard questions in the light of the gospel,” and the humility to follow those questions in the face of the swift, seductive, and expedient answers offered by the surrounding culture at Philippi.
Most Christians will not ever entertain the burning question of whether they are called to be a monk. But many have asked the worthwhile question of whether God is calling them to deepen their self-offering through the daily practice of living under a Rule, a Pattern, a Rhythm. As individuals, it is easy to find the consistency of our prayer, the zeal of our service, or the clarity of our values becoming blurry at the edges. A Rule reminds us: you are not meant to carry the cross of Christ alone.
As you all at Holy Comforter explore the process of creating a Rule of Life that reflects your distinctive way of following Jesus, we Brothers of the Society of Saint John the Evangelist pray that the questions you ask will shape and reshape both your understanding and experience of community in Christ – its challenges, its rewards, and its witness to our world.
Amen.
- Society of Saint John the Evangelist, The Rule of the Society of Saint John the Evangelist, chapter 44, “The Process of Mutual Review.” ↩

